A group of New Zealand parents are calling for guidelines to be drawn up around the use of digital technology in schools.
The group, most of whom have professional backgrounds in health and education, believe that the use of digital technology in schools can have great potential for learning, but that it’s use needs to be purposeful and moderate.
Some New Zealand primary schools have near full digital immersion, with one-to-one iPad initiatives starting even as early as Year One.
Founder, Paediatric Physiotherapist Julie Cullen, says “there are many different views on device use in schools, and those views may all have valid points, but this is a discussion we need to be having. An increasing number of studies are finding that high screen use is associated with negative impacts on children’s health and well-being. We know that most young people in New Zealand have well over the recommended amount of recreational screen time.”
While all screen content is not equal, the total time spent on devices is also important.
“Schools and communities need to be working together, and asking questions – is it OK for our teenagers to spend ten hours or more on a screen per day? Because with 4 or 5 hours of school use, a few more for homework and then recreational use, that’s not an unusual amount. Is it OK for primary students to do most of their work learning on screens, another hour for homework, and then a few more for recreation? Do our 5 year olds need one-to-one iPad initiatives?
“To have children using screens for several hours at school and then to say it’s their parents responsibility to make sure they have enough balance is an issue. Particularly when schools are asking for children to bring a personal device with them and then to take it home to work on. Schools and communities need to work together to address these issues.’
Cullen notes that while the evidence for computer use in education is, at best, mixed, an overall review of research by the OECD shows that moderate screen use seems to have some positive impact on educational outcomes.
However, high screen use in school, defined as more than 1 to 2 time per week or around 25 minutes a day, is associated with lower outcomes, particularly in areas such as mathematics and reading literacy. Surprisingly the latest OECD report, as well as recent Australian research, shows that high screen use in schools is also associated with lower digital skills.
Even young people themselves are saying they have concerns, with data from the Pew Research Centre in 2018 showing that 90% of adolescents agree that ‘spending too much time on-line is a problem for teenagers’, and over 50% report trying to cut down on their smartphone use, mostly unsuccessfully.
The group notes “Digital technology will be a big part of our children’s future. We recognise that understanding how digital technologies work and gaining digital skills is going to be very important for children to have equal opportunities on leaving school. We also recognise that the introduction of devices into schools has been well intended. However, if studies show that moderate screen use can have the best outcomes for educational achievement and gaining digital skills, and increasing evidence is linking high screen use to negative impacts on the health and well-being of young people – we need to be talking about this.”
“More research is needed and digital technology is constantly changing, but our kids deserve our best effort to look at the research that does exist, and to make evidence-based decisions.”
“It is time for the New Zealand educational system to look carefully at what is best for our children, both now and in the future. We need to re-evaluate the use of screens to teach basic skills such as reading and writing. We need to develop sensible limits for device access and reduce distractions for both children and adolescents. We need to allow children the space to develop social skills and relationships through real interactions with humans, not screens. The digital curriculum could achieve great things for our children and our schooling if implemented in an evidence-based way.”